More US commercial property loans stressed

Source : Business Times - 8 Jan 2009

Credit market reluctant to renew financing of loans

The number of stressed commercial property loans increased at an accelerated pace in December, challenging a major segment of the US bond market that has shown recent signs of stability.

The percentage of commercial mortgages placed with companies that specialise in servicing troubled loans jumped 0.32 percentage point to 1.61 per cent, the highest in about four years, according to JPMorgan Chase & Co.

Erosion in fundamentals of commercial property has been long forecast as the slowing economy reduces demand for office space and cuts revenues from hotels and retail shops. Investors in 2008 fled commercial mortgage-backed securities (CMBS) as signs of recession led to increased aversion from risky assets, even as overall delinquencies fell far short of those in US residential real estate.

Many analysts claimed that the increase in CMBS risk premiums has been excessive, even under catastrophic loss estimates, having been fuelled by funds seeking cash or reducing borrowings as the financial crisis deepened. But a rally in the US$700 billion CMBS market in December is sputtering this week amid further erosion in market fundamentals and fresh signs of investor selling.

‘Sellers may have sensed a good exit point after the December (price improvement), but the CMBS fundamentals remain weak and are unquestionably worsening,’ said Chris Sullivan, chief investment officer at the United Nations Federal Credit Union in New York.

So-called special servicers are grappling with a credit market reluctant to renew financing on billions of dollars in loans, even those backed by relatively strong properties.

Borrowers with loans at or near maturity, including mall-owner General Growth Properties, are being forced to seek extensions from creditors or sell assets to avert bankruptcy.

Loans on retail and office properties appear to be leading those on servicer ‘watch lists’, or have been transferred to special servicers, said Erin Stafford, an analyst at bond rater DBRS in Chicago. Multifamily property delinquencies are high, but may reveal more ‘borrower issues’ than a fundamental problems with the properties, she said.

Possible solutions for a delinquent loan on The Mix at Southbridge - a 20,000 square foot Scottsdale, Arizona, retail centre - included modifying the mortgage, offering deed in lieu of foreclosure or an asset sale as the borrower tries to win leases, according to a DBRS report on the 2007 Bear Stearns-issued CMBS that contains the loan.

The special servicer on a delinquent loan for the 9,895 sq ft Natomas Crossing retail centre in Sacramento, California, was making progress on a forbearance agreement before the borrower decided to sell, DBRS reported.

But commercial property values are falling after being propped up in the 2005 to 2007 period by lax underwritings and investors eager to boost paltry yields with risky debt.

‘I think you’re going to see people giving back the keys and saying ‘We don’t think the asset is worth the debt’,’ Mark Weiss, president of McLean, Virginia- based JER Investors Trust, said in a December interview. ‘I think you will see people say ‘My cash flow is great, there’s just no financing today, so work through it with me.’ It’s going to be all across the spectrum.’

The market for commercial property is not dead, however. Glimcher Realty Trust on Tuesday said that it sold its Olathe, Kansas- based Great Mall for US$20.5 million and repaid a US$30 million mortgage that was to mature on Jan 12.